PiePie's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[EGL01]

Good

for a little loop I can see this bieng used in a movie or game here on newgrounds that is why I gave you an 8 because it has potential.

Loop was very good simple and effetive

Keep them coming!

[Aphasiaphile]

hmm

well for one I still see the uniqueness you seem to be having on msotof your songs.

but thsi song did not quite cut it for me i felt like something was missing.

I did like however how you made it come together but then it stop and just contintued with the same thing.

Good but not great

PiePie

Creamy-T responds:

yeh, this isn't a song i look back on and like much. just a little weak overall.

thanks for the feedback

[Vigilante Superhooker]

Hmm

this was actually very good it was also unique and bieng unique is always a good thing for music stand out of the crowd.

I very good song the beat was top notch

keep it up!

Creamy-T responds:

im all about trying to throw in some originality and crazy beats! thanks

[Forbidden Love-Metaljonus]

WOW!

that was sweet. this is great the sound the everything!

really good job on this one you should be proud with this song.

keep them coming!

[Introduction, Rondo et Scherzo]

Just Lovely

very nice smooth calm awsome!

you hit the spot except that some points in the song where a bit overdone.

still very good I liked it quit a bit

Keep it up!

MusicalRocky responds:

Nice, smooth, calm, and awesome, eh? Lol thanks. I really don't know what I was going for with this piece, or indeed if I was going for anything.

Some points in the song were indeed overdone. As I listen I feel that the "eroico" theme carried on a bit too long, etc...

Thanks very much for your review, PiePie

[Windaigo (2006 Mix)]

mmmmm

I have my feet on the subwoofer and I could tell oyu it feels awsome!

anyways this song is great I really liked it.

liked what you did with it kept the beat and you made it always flow also liked how you kept on changing all the time.

Very good!

Dj-Fanta5t1c responds:

hehehe thx, i wanted a really good fast techno beat. so i made it ^_^ i htink future mixes will be much more amzazing. thx for the review ^_^

[Bass Force (Short Mix)]

Hmm

not bad but still not great.

I liked it I love lots of bass and this song had it.

except it was a little on the extra side.

anyways

its was good but a bit to simple you should of used this as a base then add some stuff to it to make it really good.

I think a version 2 is in order!

Dj-Fanta5t1c responds:

hehe a version 2 would not be a bad idea!!! i really want the flp back tho casue it was such an awesome song!!! =( o well ill get over it. thx a ton for the review again!

[Misantropia]

Well

Don't take my low score as an insult. I rather give an honest review than some bullshit I got out of my ass.

The good news is that you can improve down the song you started doing like a solo that was awsome on guitar its just there was so much buzz that it took away from it.

Anyways try making everything with more clairity

Keep on trying!

darkkloud responds:

yes, as many have said, im not so good with the mastering proocess. and no, i dont take it as an unsult, i apreciate the honesty

[aflXln Pirates ofthe Caribbean]

Nice try

I really enjoyed the movies so i like this to bad you didn't add some extra flavour to it...

I didn't think you where going to play the main beat when it kicks in but you did I was amazed that you could pull it off.

nice stuff

afliXion responds:

Well, when I do a piano arrangement of a movie I like to keep to the original as much as I can. And for a song like this, theres not much else you can do to add flavor except add a few notes and octaves.
The fast part had more than enough flavor I'd say, and I like the contrast with that and the beginning.